Journal of Arid Regions Geographic Studies

Journal of Arid Regions Geographic Studies

Genealogy of Urban Renewal: The Problematization of Tehran’s Neighborhoods in the Discipline of Planning during the Second Pahlavi Period (1941–1979)

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
Department of Urban and Regional Planning, Faculty of Arts, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
Aim: Every discourse produces its own space. Therefore, various urban policies are viewed as mediators of order and systems of spatial relations, aligning with centralized discourse. Corresponding to such an encounter, at the concrete level of metropolitan areas, some neighborhoods that are left out of the limits of the central order are exposed to a special way of naming and subsequently called by the power apparatus. Urban renewal is considered one of the policies for shaping and reshaping spatial relations, which, more than ever, seeks to optimize economic and social relations in space in line with the interests of central policies.
Method: This research critically examines urban policies within the contexts identified as outdated during the second Pahlavi period. The historical perspective has been able to make visible some invisible layers of spatial relations in the studied period in Tehran.
Findings: The research findings, spanning policy, planning, and concrete situations, reveal that the central neighborhoods of Tehran became increasingly problematic for management during the second Pahlavi period, primarily due to the capital's designation as the center of a great civilization.
Conclusion: Undoubtedly, a genealogical reading of urban renewal policies and reflections on the emergence of textures that are now considered worn out can provide grounds for democratic planning and policymaking in the discourse arena. A plan that considers the spatial differences.
Innovation: The current research can be a kind of activism in the concrete and discursive field. The reading of spatial relations from a historical perspective can make the procedures of transforming discourse policies into reality visible to researchers and ultimately provide the possibility of forming different forms of urban policies in the planning system of Iran.
Keywords

Subjects


1. Introduction  

In different periods, the management apparatuses have various ways of dealing with social and spatial situations. Therefore, each discursive order can have its own space. In this sense, various urban policies are considered mediators of regulating spatial relations in centralized discourse. In such cases, at the concrete level of cities, some urban neighborhoods that have been removed from the boundaries of the central areas or have been set aside are exposed to such behaviors and subsequently called upon by the apparatus of power. Urban renewal is considered one of the policies for improving spatial relations, which, more than ever, seeks to optimize social and spatial relations in economic terms and through central policies.

2. Materials and Methods

The current research critically examines urban policies in contexts identified as problematic or outdated during the second Pahlavi period, through a historical review.

3. Results and Discussion

The Problematics of Central Neighborhoods in Tehran: Reorganizing the Procedures for the Distribution of Benefits and Resources.

For the implementation of urban development and renovation plans in Tehran, the first step is to emphasize the necessity of some legal reforms focused on ownership. Such emphasis is to encourage social groups to accept the new boundaries of ownership in urban space. In fact, the prerequisite for any form of physical renovation in the first step is the renovation of thoughts and attachments. During this period, in addition to encouraging people to cross the thresholds of their property ownership, some relevant institutions were also formed to advance renovation in Tehran. The South Tehran Rehabilitation and Development Organization is one of the aforementioned institutions.

Renovation Priorities: In this period, Tehran's neighborhoods are generally divided into five areas for renovation.

First Area: This area has the most unsuitable physical and environmental conditions. In addition, the highest unemployment rate is observed in this area due to the lack of local employment facilities and severe and continuous migration. Gode Mirza Mashala, Bazaar, Darvaze Ghar, Oudlajan, Amirieh, and Mehrabad are among the neighborhoods located in this area.

Second Area: In this area, the renovation and rehabilitation of the Mokhtari and Darkhungah neighborhoods, Chaleh-e-Meydan, Amin-e-Sultan Square, Eshrat-abad, and Shahnaz Square are the center of attention.

Third Area: In this area, the renovation and rehabilitation of the neighborhoods of Brianek, Darvazeh Qazvin, Imamzadeh Hassan, Dolab, and Khorasan Square have been emphasized.

Fourth Area: In this area, the need to improve the neighborhoods of Salsabil, Ariana, Javadieh, Khazaneh Gharbi, Arak, Gar-Mashin, Darvazeh Ghar, Najafabad, and Hashemabad has been emphasized.

Fifth Area: In this area, the renovation and rehabilitation of the neighborhoods of Heshmatiyeh, Pasteur, Daneshgah, Ekbatan, Gorgan, Darvazeh Shemiran, Tselihat, Doshan-e-Tepe, Koy Siman, and Shahr-e Rey have been emphasized.

4. Conclusions

One of the most important forces that fundamentally makes urban relations problematic for the management system in this era is the global shift from a situation based on rural relations to urban relations. Such changes on a global scale have affected spatial relations within the country to a lesser extent. The manifestation of such effects can be seen at various levels of policymaking, planning, and implementation. Without reducing the spatial developments in Tehran to changes in external conditions, it is necessary to point out that, in addition to other major developments that are outside the concrete situation of Tehran, some internal and concrete considerations also push the management system towards a type of spatial management and order and systematization during this period. In this regard, it can be said that the significant changes that occurred in the middle contexts of Tehran during the Reza Khan era affected local relations in the center of Tehran in such a way that they eventually gradually became the center of attention as neighborhoods with various problems from the early 1920s onwards. In this sense, it can be said that some large-scale interventions during the first Pahlavi era basically intervened in the fabric of the central neighborhoods of Tehran in order to maximize their adaptability to automobile-oriented developments. During the second Pahlavi era, the development pattern of Tehran also fundamentally changed, and through linear development, the city grew more and more towards the northern and western regions. Accordingly, the neighborhoods that were the focus of interventions during the first Pahlavi era once again remained as spatial conditions surplus to development and were exposed to modernization policies.

5. Conflicts of Interest & Funding

  • The manuscript did not receive a grant from any organization
  • The authors declare no conflict of interest.

6. Acknowledgment

·        The authors are thankful to all people who have supported this research.

 
Andalib, Alireza. 2015. Tehran City Renovation in the Past Half Century: The Way in Which Worn-Out Urban Fabrics Emerged and Expanded; The Effect of Urban Development and Renovation Policies on the Emergence and Expansion of Worn-Out Urban Fabrics in Tehran. [In Persian] 
Bayat, Asef. 2011. Life as Politics: How Ordinary People Change the Middle East, translated by Fatemeh Sadeghi. Amsterdam University Press. [In Persian]      
Bayat, Asef. 2010. Tehran, City of Paradoxes. New Left Review, Issue 66. [In Persian]          
Council of Ministers. 1976. Statute of the South Tehran Improvement and Development Organization. [In Persian]
Cuthbert, Alexander R. 2017. The Form of Cities: Political Economy and Urban Design, translated by Hamidreza Parsi and Arezo Aflatoni. Tehran University Press. [In Persian]   
Dehghani, Ava, and Tofigh, Ebrahim. 2017. Genealogy of the Order of Tehran Today: Focusing on the Role of the Article Five Commission. Iranian Sociology, 18th Year, No. 2, Summer 2017. [In Persian]
Dreyfus, Hubert, and Rabineau, Paul. 2021. Michel Foucault: Beyond Structuralism and Hermeneutics, translated by Hossein Bashirieh. Ney Publishing. [In Persian]    
Erfanianjam, Hamid. 2017. The Worn-Out Urban Fabric: A Treatable Disease. Donyaye Eqtesad Newspaper, No. 4093. [In Persian]        
First Comprehensive Plan of Tehran. 1964. Volumes One, Two, Three, Four, and Five. [In Persian
Foucault, Michel. 2020. Security, Territory, Population: Lectures at the Collège de France, 1977–78, translated by Seyyed Mohammad Javad Seyyidi. Cheshmeh Publications. [In Persian]          
Foucault, Michel. 2011. Society Must Be Defended, translated by Reza Najafzadeh. Tehran: Rukhdad Now Publishing. [In Persian]        
Foucault, Michel. 2008. Discipline and Punish: The Birth of Prison, translated by Niko Sarkhosh and Afshin Jahandideh. Ney Publications. [In Persian]         
Foucault, Michel. 1986. Space, Knowledge, and Power. In P. Rabinow (Ed.), The Foucault Reader. Penguin.
Ghamami, Majid. 2013. Studying the Status of Urbanism and Urban and Regional Planning in Contemporary Iran. Tehran: Afrand. [In Persian]        
Habibi, Mohsen. 2021. From Shar to City: A Historical Analysis of the Concept of the City and Its Physical Mapping. Thought and Impact, 19th Edition. Tehran University Press. [In Persian]           
Hadi-Zanuz, Behrvarz. 2010. Study of the Economic Planning System in Iran: Pre-Revolutionary Period. Research Center of the Islamic Consultative Assembly. [In Persian]      
Hakami, Mahmoud. 1962. Sociological History of Tehran and Its Current Social Composition. Tehran Social Issues Seminar, Institute of Social Studies and Research, University of Tehran. [In Persian]
Jamshidiha, Gholamreza, and Bayangani, Bahman. 2011. Foucault, History and Historical Methodology. Barg-e Farhang, No. 23, 174–199. [In Persian]        
Khord Engineering Group. 2019. The Story of Development in Iran: From the Prime Ministership of Amir Kabir (1948) to the Victory of the Islamic Revolution (1978). Lawh Fekr Publications. [In Persian]
Lavalin, Davis International. 1976. Master Plan of the Pahlavi Shahistan. [In Persian]             
Melli Bank Magazine, No. 98. 1948. History of the Seven-Year Development Plan of Iran, prepared by the Department of Economic and Financial Statistics and Surveys of the National Bank of Iran. [In Persian]
National Assembly. 1968. Urban Development and Renovation Law. [In Persian]  
National Assembly. 1941. Road Development Law. [In Persian]        
Orcad, Bernard. 1996. Tehran, the Two-Hundred-Year Capital. Tehran Technical and Engineering Consultants Organization and the French Society of Iranology in Iran. [In Persian]             
Pahlavi, Mohammad Reza. 2007. Towards a Great Civilization. Los Angeles: Pars Publications. [In Persian]
Planning and Budget Organization. 1964. Report on the Implementation of the Second Seven-Year Plan. [In Persian]       
Rahnamai, Taghi. 1980. The Expansion of Tehran and the Transformation of Its Villages. Geographical Research, No. 16. [In Persian]        
Rahnamai, Mohammad Taghi, 1996, The expansion of Tehran and the transformation of its villages, in Tehran, the two-hundred-year capital, under the supervision of Shahriar Adl and Bernard Orcard, the Organization of Technical and Engineering Consultants of Tehran and the French Society of Iranology in Iran. [In Persian]
Shever, 1964, The Three Stages Of Urban Planning In Tehran, Translated By Mehdi Motmani, Tehran Social Issues Seminar, Institute Of Social Studies And Research, University Of Tehran. [In Persian]
Talebi, Hamed; Hojjat, Eesa; Farzian, Mohammad; 2013, Studying Roles Of Government, Public, And Architects In Emersion Of Low-Rise Housing Complexes During The Second Pahlavi Period, Fine Arts:Architecture And Urban Study, Vol 19, No 1. [In Persian]        
Tehran Social Issues Seminar, 1962, Institute Of Social Studies And Research, University Of Tehran. [In Persian]
Tofigh, Ibrahim, 2014, Interview With “Ibrahim Tofigh” About The Mechanisms, Becomings, And Logics Of A Regulated Chaos | Sharq Newspaper, No. 2243, March 2. [In Persian]           
Yazdanian, Ahmad, Pourjafar, Mohamadreza And Rafieian, Mojtaba, 2024, Thinking Space, Considerations About Spatial Regulations And Spatiality Of Policies, Arid Regions Geographic Studies, 15(57), 84–64. [In Persian]      
Yousefi, Hamid Reza, 2015, Spatial Representation Of The Hegemonic Project Of Great Civilization In The Late Pahlavi Era In Tehran, Case Study: Shahestan Pahlavi. [In Persian]        
Zimran, Mohammad, 2014, Michel Foucault: Knowledge And Power, Tehran, Hermes, 7th Edition. [In Persian]
Zieleniec, A. 2007, Space and Social Theory, Space And Social Theory, 1–224.

  • Receive Date 01 December 2024
  • Revise Date 18 January 2025
  • Accept Date 18 January 2025
  • Publish Date 01 November 2025