Journal of Arid Regions Geographic Studies

Journal of Arid Regions Geographic Studies

Identification and Analysis of Key Drivers Affecting the Urban Water Management Using Futures Studies Approach A Case Study: Ardabil City

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 Department of Geography and Urban planning, Faculty of Literature and Humanities, Branch Ardabil, University Azad Islamic, Ardabil, Iran
2 Department of Geography, Faculty of Social Sciences, University Payam Noor, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
Aim: This research is applied in terms of purpose and descriptive-analytical in terms of method and nature, aiming to identify and analyze the critical variables in the water management of Ardabil city.
Materials & Methods: To collect the required data, library studies, articles, research papers, and upstream documents were used. Additionally, 30 experts and specialists in the water sector of Ardabil were selected using the snowball sampling method. Subsequently, a Delphi questionnaire was distributed in two stages among the expert panel members to determine the influential factors in Ardabil's water sector. Thirty-five variables across seven main indicators were selected, and a variable matrix table was formed to score and determine the relationships between the variables. In the second stage, the MICMAC software was used to identify the key drivers, and the matrix table scores were entered into the software.  
Finding: After calculations by the MICMAC software, 12 variables were identified as critical variables. The results revealed that among the main indicators, the technical indicator had the most significant impact. However, the variables "increasing water prices" and "subsidy removal" had the highest level of importance and priority among the 12 key variables.  
Conclusion: The results indicated that to address Ardabil's water issue, special attention must be paid to variables such as increasing water prices and subsidy removal, preventing migration to the city, investment in infrastructure, improving the water distribution system, and water management. These should be prioritized in the work agenda of Ardabil's city managers.
Innovation: The most significant issue was the lack of a futures studies perspective in addressing Ardabil's water challenges. Additionally, the use of diverse variables and different indicators to identify key factors in Ardabil's water management through MICMAC software played a fundamental role in the research outcomes.
Keywords

Subjects


Extended Abstract

1. Introduction

According to statistics announced by international institutions, there is a challenging gap in the world between the ability to supply water and the intensity of water demand, which, if not controlled by a set of management solutions, will become a place of tension and conflict on local, regional, national, and global scales. Other crisis-causing factors include the level of income of individuals, population growth, the level of investment in water infrastructure, water management, technological changes in the agricultural and industrial sectors, and decision-making policies, which lead to other scenarios for the future of water. In the meantime, Iran is among the arid and semi-arid countries of the world and is considered one of the most water-scarce countries in the world due to low precipitation and inappropriate temporal and spatial distribution of precipitation. Therefore, despite the consequences and effects of the water crisis in the environmental sphere and even the social space, such as local and regional disputes and conflicts in some provinces of the country, the necessary attention, sensitivity, and concern among the general public and even experts and policymakers have not yet emerged as they should. Incorrect water management on a government scale for a long time, the lack of strategic planning regarding water safety issues in the country, and the weakness of policies have doubled the need to revise the goals and policies ahead in order to manage the water crisis.

2. Materials and Methods

In this research, based on the nature of the research, quantitative and qualitative methods, data analysis, and extraction of indicators have been used. The main goal of this research is to identify and analyze the key variables that are important in the water crisis issue in Ardabil city. In two stages, the Delphi questionnaire was distributed among the experts. In the first step, the experts identified the indicators in general, and after monitoring and integrating the indicators, in the second step, the experts identified and selected the important and influential factors in the water issue of Ardabil city using the Delphi questionnaire. After selecting the indicators, a matrix of variables was formed for scoring and entering the scores into the software. In the next stage, these scores were entered into the software by forming a matrix in the MICMAC software, and after calculations were performed by the software, the key factors and main variables affecting the water issue of Ardabil city were identified.

3. Results and Discussion

In the first step, the experts identified the general indicators, and after monitoring and integrating the indicators, in the second step, the experts identified and selected important and influential factors in the water sector of Ardabil using a Delphi questionnaire. Finally, by analyzing the second round of questionnaires, 35 variables in 7 different areas, including economic, managerial, socio-cultural, demographic, environmental, agricultural, geographical, and technical, were selected as the primary variables in the water sector of Ardabil. By examining the results obtained from the MICMAC software, 12 variables were selected as the main factors in the water sector of Ardabil, which include: increasing water prices and eliminating subsidies, migration to the city, investment in water infrastructure, improving the water distribution system and preventing water leakage, water sector management measures, expanding agricultural land, population growth, the impact of rainfall changes, using low-water-demanding plant species, improving water use efficiency, deterioration of the urban water network, and the culture of water consumption patterns among urban households. These factors were selected based on the direct and indirect impact they had on these variables and obtained the highest score. By further examining the final variables, it was determined that, according to the divided indicators, all the indicators used in the research had an impact on the water sector of Ardabil city. So that among the 7 main indicators, the technical indicator with 3 variables had the most impact, and the economic, demographic, and environmental-agricultural indicators had 2 variables each, and the managerial, geographical, and socio-cultural indicators had 1 variable each. This shows that the water is a multidimensional issue, and all indicators have an impact on improving the situation.

4. Conclusions

In this study, based on the output of the MICMAC software, it was determined that the factors that have been identified as key and important drivers in preventing or reducing the effects of the water crisis in Ardabil can play an effective role in solving this crisis, such that raising the price of water and eliminating water subsidies are considered important factors in solving the water crisis. Therefore, if the increase in the price of drinking water for urban consumers who do not comply with the consumption pattern is so high that consumption outside the defined standard places a heavy financial burden on consumers, there will definitely be savings in its consumption. The second factor is migration to Ardabil. If this factor is placed next to the population growth factor, it will be seen that the increase in the population will definitely have the consequences of a shortage of resources. Also, planning in the agricultural sector should be carried out in such a way that water is used optimally in this sector and waste and inappropriate use of water are prevented by using modern irrigation systems. Also, the change in cultivation pattern should occur in accordance with each climate, and the water resources consumed in the products should be allocated in accordance with that climate. Considering that one of the final variables in the water crisis in Ardabil city was management measures in the field of water, as a result, paying attention to culture building, optimal planning in the field of water, determining the type of cultivation, cultivation pattern, as well as attracting investors in the urban water infrastructure and agricultural irrigation sectors, and attracting budget from the government in the water infrastructure sector, are effective measures in this field.

5. Acknowledgment & Funding

The manuscript did not receive a grant from any organization.

6. Conflict of Interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

Afshari, S., Sepahvand, F., & Naderi mahdei, K. (2025). A prosprctive Analysis of How to Realize Local Water Governance in the Qarachai Watershed. Iranian Agricultural Extension and Education Journal, 20(2), 275-294. 10.22034/iaeej.2025.451844.1794 [In Persian]
Aftabi, Z., Kaviani Rad, M., & Kardan moghadam, H. (2023). Explaining the Future Scenarios of the Hydro Political Relations of the Border Rivers of Iran and Iraq. Water and Irrigation Management, 13(2), 487-507. 20.1001.1.22516298.1402.13.2.12.6 [In Persian]
Aghamiri, H. S., & Rahmani, B. (2019). The Impact of Rural Migration on Food Security with Emphasis on Water Resources Case study: villages of Khansar city of Isfahan province. Geography, 16(59), 56-76. https://mag.iga.ir/article_246083.html [In Persian]
Ardabil Meteorological Administration.(2025).Meteorological Yearbook 2024 of Ardabil Province. https://ardmet.ir/fa/show/95/pages [In Persian]
Aromolaran, A. K., Ademiluyi, I. O., Sotola, A. E., Wole-Alo, F. I., Aromiwura, O. A., & Ogunsuyi, O. E. (2019). Effect of water scarcity on households’ livelihoods in Iwoye-Ketu Area of Ogun State, Nigeria. Journal of Water and Land Development, 43(5), 9-18. DOI:10.2478/jwld-2019-0058
Asiabi-Hir, R., Mostafazadeh, R., Raoof, M., & Esmali-Ouri, A. (2019). Evaluating surface water sustainability of Ardabil Province watersheds. Watershed Engineering and Management, 11(4), 984-998.  https://doi.org/10.22092/ijwmse.2018.109649.1277 [In Persian]
Asiabi Hir, R., Mostafazadeh, R., Raoof, M., & Esmali Ouri, A. (2017). Multi-criteria evaluation of water poverty index spatial variations in some watersheds of Ardabil Province. Journal of Ecohydrology4(4), 997-1009. 10.22059/ije.2017.63231 [In Persian]
Baktiyari, N., Zanganeh, Y., Taghvai, M., & Zanganeh, M. (2020). Study of spatial pattern of domestic water consumption in Isfahan and Analysis of Socio-cultural Factors Affecting on it. Human Geography Research, 52 (2), 515-531. 10.22059/jhgr.2018.252555.1007647 [In Persian]
Bănăduc, D., Simić, V., Cianfaglione, K., Barinova, S., Afanasyev, S., Öktener, A., & Curtean-Bănăduc, A. (2022). Freshwater as a sustainable resource and generator of secondary resources in the 21st century: Stressors, threats, risks, management and protection strategies, and conservation approaches.  International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 19(24), 16570.      DOI:10.3390/ijerph192416570
Biswas, A. K., & Tortajada, C. (2019). Water crisis and water wars: myths and realities.  International Journal of Water Resources Development, 35(5), 727731.  DOI:10.1080/07900627.2019.1636502
Bolt, A., Dincer, I., & Agelin-Chaab, M. (2020). Experimental study of hydrogen production process with aluminum and water.  International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 45(28), 14232-14244. DOI:10.1016/j.ijhydene.2020.03.160
Daneshvar Vousoughi, F., & Dinpashoh, Y. (2013). Trends of Groundwater Quality of Ardabil Plain Using the Spearman Method. Journal of Environmental Studies, 38(4), 17-28. 10.22059/jes.2013.29860 [In Persian]
Fadaei Deh Cheshmeh, M. (2019). Semantic representation of water crisis: Semantic representation of water crisis from the perspective of contextual method in Chaharmahal and Bakhtiari province (Borojen, Farrokhshahr, Saman), First Edition, Tehran: Danesh pajoohan sharif yar publications. [In Persian]
Food and Agriculture Organization of The United Nations. (2024). Progress on the Level of Water Stress. Mid- term Status of SDG indicator 6.4.2 and acceleration needs, with special focus on food security. Rome. https://www.fao.org/platforms/water-scarcity/Knowledge/knowledge-products/detail/progress-on-the-level-of-water-stress--mid-term-status-of-sdg-indicator-6.4.2
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. (2012). Coping with water scarcity, publications by Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations      https://www.fao.org/4/i3015e/i3015e.pdf
Ghafari, S., Moradi, H., & Modares, R. (2018). Comparison of Temporal and Spatial Changes of Groundwater Level in Isfahan-Borkhar, Najafabad and Chadegan Plains. Physical Geography Research, 50(1), 141-160. 10.22059/jphgr.2018.226430.100699 [In Persian]
George-Williams, H. E. M., Hunt, D. V. L., & Rogers, C. D. F. (2024). Foresight for Sustainable Water Futures in Sub-Saharan Africa: A Systematic Review. Sustainability, 16(20), 8874.      doi.org/10.3390/su16208874
Gupta, R., & Kumar, G. (2018). Scenario planning for water resource management in semiarid zone. Physics  10.1016/j.pce.2017.12.004
Haji Ghadiri, S.,  &  Godarzi, G. (2022). Future Scenarios of Water Crisis in 2050 Horizon. Journal of Strategic Management and Future Studies, 5(1), 1-19. https://journal.tolouemehr.ac.ir/article_154799.html [In Persian]
Karimi Nejad, M., Golshani, A., & Bustani, F. (2019). Policy Making Pathology of Water Crisis in Iran: A Foresight Approach. Strategic Quarterly Journal , 27(4), 95-124. 20.1001.1.10283102.1397.27.4.4.4  [In Persian]
Khosravipour, B., & Soleimani H. K. (2020). The water crisis is a societal issue requiring interdisciplinary scientific collaboration. Environment, Natural Resources and Sustainable Development Studies Journal, 11(1), 1-4. https://shij.ir/ensd/upload/ensd/Content/200621_00/ENSD-No11-Digital.pdf [In Persian]
Kippenberger,T. (1999). Pitfalls in scenario Planning. The Antidote, 4 (4), 32-33.      https://doi.org/10.1108/EUM0000000006712
Kosow, H.,  Brauner, S., Brumme, A., Hauser, W.,  Hölzlberger, F., Moschner, J., Rübbelke, D., Vögele, S., & Weimer-Jehle, W. (2024). Uncharted water conflicts ahead: mapping the scenario space for Germany in the year 2050. Frontiers in Water. 6. 1492336. DOI:10.3389/frwa.2024.1492336
Lehane, S. (2014). The Iranian Water Crisis, Global Food and Water Crises Research Programme, Published by Future Directions International Pty Ltd. https://apo.org.au/sites/default/files/resource-files/2014-02/apo-nid38233.pdf
Maleki, S., Moradi, H., & Amanpour, S. (2024). Structural analysis of key drivers affecting water stress in Iranian cities (Study case: Ahvaz metropolis). JFCV, 5 (3), 135-163. http://jvfc.ir/article-1-327-fa.html [In Persian]
Malekmohammadi, B., Eskandari, T., Zebardast, L., & Azizi, A. (2017). Integrated Environmental Assessment of Groundwater Depletion in Ardebil Plain for Management Solutions. Journal of Environmental Studies, 42(4), 687-707. 10.22059/jes.2017.60935 [In Persian]
Mohamed, M. M., El-Shorbagy, W., Kizhisseri, Mohamed I.,  Chowdhury, R., & McDonald, A. (2020). Evaluation of policy scenarios for water resources planning and management in an arid region. Hydrology: Regional Studies,  32, 100758.  https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejrh.2020.100758
Mohammadi, A. , Pishagar, E. , Noori, S., & Arzhangie, H. (2019). Identifying Vulnerable Neighborhoods in the City in Terms of City Water Network Events Using GIS. Case Study: Ardabil City. Emergency Management, 8(1), 91-106. 20.1001.1.23453915.1398.8.1.8.4 [In Persian]
Owusu, P. A., Asumadu-Sarkodie, S., & Ameyo, P. (2016). A review of Ghana’s water resource management and the future prospect.  Cogent Engineering, 3(1), 1164275      DOI:10.1080/23311916.2016.1164275
Pluchinotta, I., Pagano, A., Vilcan, T., Ahilan, S., Kapetas, L., & Maskrey, S. (2021). A participatory system dynamics model to investigate sustainable urban water management in Ebbsfleet Garden City. Sustainable Cities and Society,(67)102709. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scs.2021.102709
Rabiei, H., razaghi, R., kaviani rad, M., & khourani, A. (2020). Analysis of the security consequences of the water crisis in Hormozgan Province. Quarterly Journal of Security Studies, 19(70), 125-155.  https://fzr.amniat.fstc.ac.ir/article_11.html?lang=en [In Persian]
Rahmani, A., Vaziri Nezhad, R., Ahmadi Nia. H., & Rezaeian, M. (2020). Methodological Principles and Applications of the Delphi Method: A Narrative Review. JRUMS, 19 (5) :515-538. 10.29252/jrums.19.5.515 [In Persian]
Regional Water Company of Ardabil.(2025). Ardabil Province Regional Water Report. www.arrw.ir [In Persian]
Renaud, F., & Wirkus, L. (2012). Water, climate change and human security: Conflict and migration. In H. Bigaa (Ed.), The global water crisis: Addressing an urgent security issue (pp. 34–45). Papers for the InterAction Council, 2011–2012. Hamilton, Canada: UNU-INWEH
Rosegrant, M.W., Cai, X., & Cline, S. A. (2002). World Water and Food to 2025: Dealing with Scarcity. Washington DC, International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI) https://www.worldfoodprize.org/documents/filelibrary/images/borlaug_dialogue/2002/transcripts/rosegrant_transcript_F2A98817596C1.pdf
Rezayan, A., & Rezayan, A. H. (2016). Future studies of water crisis in Iran based on processing scenario. Journal of Ecohydrology, 3(1), 1-17. 10.22059/ije.2016.59185 [In Persian]
Saeedi, J., & Sadeghi Deh Cheshmeh, S. (2023). Analysis of scenarios to security consequences of the water crisis in Chaharmahal and Bakhtiari province. Geography, 21(76), 181-210. http://dor.net/dor20.1001.1.27833739.1402.21.76.9.0 [In Persian]
Shahedi, M., & Talebi Hossein Abad, F. (2014). Introducing few indices to evaluate the balance of Water Resources and sustainable development (Case Study: Qareh-Qum Basin in Iran). Journal of Water and Sustainable Development, 1(1), 73-79. 10.22067/jwsd.v1i1.34603 [In Persian]
Taheri Demneh, M., kazemi, M., & safari. Gh. K. (2023). Foresight of the Water Issue in Isfahan. Sustainable city, 5(4), 53-71. 10.22034/jsc.2021.236478.1265 [In Persian]
Unicef.(2021). Water scarcity. Retieved from https:www.unicef.org/ wash/water-scarcity
Varamesh, S., Mohtaram Anbaran, S., & Rouhnavaz, Z. (2022). Evaluation and monitoring of the thirty-year physical expansion process of Ardabil city using satellite images. Scientific- Research Quarterly of Geographical Data (SEPEHR), 31(123), 139-153. doi.org/10.22131/sepehr.2022.699919 [In Persian]
Zali, N., & Zamanipoor, M. (2015). Systematic Analysis of Strategic Variables of Regional Development in Scenario- based Planning (Case: Mazandaran Province). Town and Country Planning, 7(1), 1-28. 10.22059/jtcp.2015.54779 [In Persian]
Volume 16, Issue 62 - Serial Number 62
(In Progress)
Winter 2026
Pages 175-195

  • Receive Date 14 April 2025
  • Revise Date 13 June 2025
  • Accept Date 13 June 2025
  • Publish Date 21 January 2026