Analyzing the Environmental Components of the Patrimonialism Theory in the Study of State Formation in Iran Before the First Pahlavi Era

Document Type : Original Article

Author

Department of Geography, Faculty of Humanities, Yazd University, Yazd, Iran

Abstract

Aim: There have been various theories about how to form an authoritarian government in Iran before the first Pahlavi, and one of the most important is the patrimonialism theory. From Max Weber's point of view, in patrimonialism, a ruling person's will be considered the only means of organizing and guiding the society. Although political power maintained its autocratic form after the first Pahlavi, the means of exercising power were applied through bureaucracy and administrative systems. Many political science thinkers have welcomed the compatibility of patrimonialism theory with the government evolution in Iran before Pahlavi. However, in this adaptation, less attention has been paid to the political-spatial requirements of Iran. 
Materials & Methods: This research has attempted to analyze the reasons for the continuation and stabilization of the patrimonial government in Iran before the first Pahlavi, with a descriptive-analytical method, and from the political geography view. 
Findings: Findings show that a set of factors, including the environmental foundations of Iran's land, the lack of water, and the lack of continuous access to it in all seasons, provides the basis for the nomadic livelihood formation in Iran. So, the emergence of cohesion between different tribes and ethnic groups was possible only with the patrimonial king's political function. In addition, the landowners' production surplus and the urban capitalist class were appropriated by the patrimonial government in the form of tax. On the other hand, the risky geopolitical situation of Iran causes only totalitarian leaders to have the ability to create an alliance between incompatible clans in Iran against hostile foreign forces. 
Conclusion: These geographical factors have created an increasing compatibility between Weber's theory of patrimonialism and the state-building Pattern in Iran before Pahlavi I.
Innovation: In general, the patrimonial king functioned due to natural and human requirements in Iran had organized the totalitarian logic that could not reduce the king's political position to alongside other social institutions.

Keywords


Abrahamian, Ervand (1974). Oriented Despotism, the Case of Iran, International Journal of Middle East Studies, 5(1): 3- 31 https://www.jstor.org/stable/162341.
Abrahamian, Ervand(2000). ‎Iran between two revolutions, Trans by Ahmad Golmohammadi & Ibrahim Fattahi, Tehran: Nye Publisher. ‏‫ای‍ران‌ ب‍ی‍ن‌ دو ان‍ق‍لاب‌ (nlai.ir) [In Persian]
Alizadeh, Ali (2006). Economic effects of western capitalist system on Iran's tribal system, Journal of modern historical reviews, 2(2): 101- 122. http://ensani.ir/fa/article/218822/. [In Persian]  
Ardestani, Ali (2012). Government foundation in Iran: theoretical or practical? Journal of Politics, 42(1): 39- 57. https://jpq.ut.ac.ir/article_29928.html[In Persian]
Ashraf, Ahmad (1980), Historical obstacles to the capitalism growth in Iran, Tehran: Zameneh Publisher. م‍وان‍ع‌ ت‍اری‍خ‍ی‌ رش‍د س‍رم‍ای‍ه‌داری‌ در ای‍ران‌: دوره‌ ق‍اج‍اری‍ه‌ (nlai.ir) [In Persian]
Bashereyeh, Hossien (2001). Obstacles to political development in Iran, Tehran: Nye Publisher. م‍وان‍ع‌ ت‍وس‍ع‍ه‌ س‍ی‍اس‍ی‌ در ای‍ران‌ (nlai.ir) [In Persian]
Bashereyeh, Hossien(2004). Political sociology: the role of social forces in political life, Tehran: Nye Publisher. جامعه‌شناسی سیاسی (nlai.ir) [In Persian]
Bay, Yarmohammad (2009). The historical geopolitics of Iran, Tehran: Cultural Research Office Press. ژئ‍وپ‍ل‍ی‍ت‍ی‍ک‌ ت‍اری‍خ‍ی‌ ای‍ران‌ (nlai.ir) [In Persian]
Cottam, Richard (1999). Nationalism in Iran, translated by Ahmad Tadayoun, Tehran: Kavir Publisher.
Foran, J (1989). The Concept of dependent Development as a key to the political economy of Qajar Iran (1800- 1925), Iranian Studies, 22(2): 5- 55. https://www.jstor.org/stable/4310667
Freund, Julien (2004). Sociologie de Max Weber, translated by Abdoul-Hussein Nikparvar, Tehran: Toteya. ج‍ام‍ع‍ه‌ش‍ن‍اس‍ی‌ م‍اک‍س‌ وب‍ر (nlai.ir) [In Persian]
Hatami, Abbas (2007). Theories of modern government in Iran, Proceeding of Modern Government in Iran, Edited by Rasoul Afzali, Tehran: Mofeid University Press. دول‍ت‌ م‍درن‌ در ای‍ران‌ (م‍ج‍م‍وع‍ه‌ م‍ق‍الات‌) (nlai.ir) [In Persian]
Issawi, Charles (1983). The Economic history of Iran 1800 - 1914, translated by Yaghoub Ajand, Tehran: Gostareh publisher. ت‍اری‍خ‌ اق‍ت‍ص‍ادی‌ ای‍ران‌ ( ع‍ص‍ر ق‍اج‍ار، ۱۱۲۱۵ - ۱۳۳۲ه‍.ق‌) (nlai.ir) [In Persian]  
Katouzeyan, Mohammadali (1994). The political economy of Iran, Translated by Mohammad-Rza Nafesi & Kambez Azizi, Tehran: Markaz publisher. اق‍ت‍ص‍اد س‍ی‍اس‍ی‌ ای‍ران‌: از م‍ش‍روطی‍ت‌ ت‍ا پ‍ای‍ان‌ س‍ل‍س‍ل‍ه‌ پ‍ه‍ل‍وی‌ (nlai.ir) [In Persian]
Katouzeyan, Mohammadali(2002). Conflict between state and nation: theory of history and politics in Iran, Translated by Alireza Teyeb, Tehran: Nye Publisher. ت‍ض‍اد دول‍ت‌ و م‍ل‍ت‌ (nlai.ir) [In Persian]

Lampton, Ann (1961). Persian Society under the Qajars, Journal of The Royal Central Asian Society, 48(2): 123- 139. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/03068376108731730

Looney, R, E (1974). The Economic Development of Iran: A Recent Survey with Projection to 1981; New York:Praeger. The Economic Development of Iran: A Recent Survey with Projections to 1981 - Robert E. Looney - Google Books
Meehan, K(2014). Tool –power: Water infrastructure as wellspring of state power, Geoforum, Vol57(1):215224. (PDF) Tool-power: water infrastructure as wellsprings of state power | Katie Meehan - Academia.edu
Mirhydar, Dorreh & Rasti, Omran(2012). Geopolitical competitions affecting the southeast side of Iran, 44(2): 21- 34. http://ensani.ir/fa/article/346711/ [In Persian]
Motevali, Abdoulah(2012). Urban foundations and power relations from the collapse of Afshariya to the death of Karim Khan Zand, journal of historical science research, 4(2): 63- 83.https://jhss.ut.ac.ir/article_30332.html[In Persian]
Naghibzadeh, Ahmad (2011). Introduction in political sociology, Tehran: Samt. درآم‍دی‌ ب‍ر ج‍ام‍ع‍ه‌ش‍ن‍اس‍ی‌ س‍ی‍اس‍ی‌ (nlai.ir) [In Persian]
Senaie, Ataalah(2006). Nomadic system and government model in Iran, Applied Research of Geographical Sciences, 5(6-7): 41- 56. https://jgs.khu.ac.ir/article-1-527-fa.html[In Persian]
Seyf, Ahmad (2001). Despotism, the question of property, and Capital accumulation, Tehran: Resanesh Publisher اس‍ت‍ب‍داد، م‍س‍ئ‍ل‍ه‌ م‍ال‍ک‍ی‍ت‌ و ان‍ب‍اش‍ت‌ س‍رم‍ای‍ه‌ در ای‍ران‌ (nlai.ir) [In Persian].
Seyf, Ahmad (2011). Crisis in despotism: The Constitutional Revolution of Iran, Tehran: Ameh. بحران در استبدادسالاری ایران (nlai.ir) [ In Persian]
Shabani, Reza (2011). The fundaments of the social history of Iran, Tehran: Ghomes Publisher. https://opac.nlai.ir/opac-prod/search/briefListSearch.do?command=FULL_VIEW&id=591098&pageStatus=1&sortKeyValue1 [In Persian]  
Solasi, Mohsen(2002).Iranian world and the globalist Iran, Tehran: Markaz Publisher. ج‍ه‍ان‌ ای‍ران‍ی‌ و ای‍ران‌ ج‍ه‍ان‍ی‌ (nlai.ir) [In Persian]
Vincent, Andrew (2006). Theories of the state, Translated by Bashereyeh, Hossien, Tehran: Nye Publisher. نظریه‌های دولت (nlai.ir) [In Persian]
Wainwright, J & Robertson, M (2003).  Territorialization, Science and the colonial state: The case of highway 55 in Minnesota, Journal of Cultural Geographies, Vol10(1): 196- 217.https://www.jstor.org/stable/44250922.
Weber, Max (1995). Wirtschaft and gesellschaft, Translated by Abbas Manouchehri & Mehrdad Torabi,   Tehran:Mola Publisher. اق‍ت‍ص‍اد و ج‍ام‍ع‍ه‌ (nlai.ir) [In Persian]